Greek Yogurt or Regular Yogurt

Which To Eat & Why

Going to the supermarket and trying to choose between Greek yogurt or regular yogurt can be challenging. Everywhere you see the ads saying how much better Greek yogurt is for your health. But is it really? Don’t you often ask yourself the questions? Is it better?  What’s the difference? How is Greek yogurt made?

Greek Yogurt or Regular Yogurt

Regular Yogurt:

The process to make either Greek yogurt or regular yogurt is the same. It’s what you do with the yogurt afterwards that makes the difference.

Here is the basic method for making yogurt:
1.    Heat the milk
2.    Cool to proper temperature  for fermentation
3.    Add cultures
4.    Ferment at  proper temperature

At that point, you have the yogurt most of us are familiar with, the kind we usually find in the grocery store. At that point, sweeteners, fruit, or other products may be added to regular yogurt. We can even drain that yogurt and make yogurt cheese.

Yogurt Cheese:

Yogurt cheese is just yogurt with the liquid (whey) drained off leaving a thicker yogurt that is very similar in use and consistency to cream cheese. In fact, it can be used much like cream cheese as a sandwich spread, appetizers, even in some salads or desserts.

Since making your own yogurt may take a bit of time, it’s pretty much hands off time, but it is very inexpensive. No additives make it, not just a frugal choice, but a very healthy option. Taking it one step further to make yogurt cheese, or yogo-cheese as some people call this gourmet food, is also a thrifty choice.

Greek yogurt:

But in between the two, yogurt and yogurt cheese, is Greek yogurt. It’s not a cheese or spread, it’s a thicker, creamier yogurt.

To make Greek yogurt, regular yogurt is strained extensively to remove liquid whey and lactose, leaving behind a thicker-textured yogurt.

While regular yogurt may be strained, if you wish, one or two times to remove the liquid whey ( I just add mine to smoothies and green drinks), Greek yogurt is strained 3 times. This gives this delicious dairy product a firmer texture, denser, and more nutrient packed.

Nutrients of Note:

Greek yogurt has close to twice the protein of regular yogurt but fewer carbohydrates.  If you need to count carbs, the thicker yogurt may be the way to go to keep the carb count lower while still filling you up.

Regular yogurt has more calcium so if this is one reason you are adding yogurt to your menu, then choose the regular kind. Regular yogurt has about 3 times as much calcium so if you aren’t meeting this nutrient through other foods then adding this to your diet may be important to your overall health needs.

Unless you add sweeteners or fruit, there is not much difference in the calorie count. Generally it’s what you add to yogurt that adds calories.


For cooking purposes: Greek yogurt is more useful since it doesn’t tend to curdle when heated for sauces or soups. But both yogurts make ideal substitutes for eggs and oils in many baking recipes.

Haven't cooked with yogurt before? You'll love this recipe.

Pork and Sweet Peppers on Noodles


One of the biggest differences, that you’ve probably already noticed at the supermarket, is the price. The cost for Greek yogurt rises sharply above regular yogurt, especially if you are comparing a true plain yogurt against the thicker one. Compare the cost of homemade versus store bought also plus regular yogurt versus Greek yogurt.  

No matter what you choose, yogurt is a nutritious and valuable dairy product to add to your food selection. In fact, some call it an ideal health food.

Greek Yogurt or Regular Yogurt; Return To Homepage

Site Build It!

Welcome to Best Pennywise Tips!

Thanks for coming by. We are currently undergoing a big transition with our website so, please bear with us as we learn and grow.

Coming soon!

Best Pennywise Newsletter (with more tips) and Your Best PennywiseTips! where you can share your tips to save time, money and help others to live frugally.

Recent Articles

  1. Make a Natural Bird Feeder Feed The Birds

    Sep 01, 18 03:55 PM

    Attract bees? Attract Butterflies? Now build a natural bird feeder to attract and keep your local bird population.

    Read More

  2. Small Healthy Changes Can (and DO) Make A Big Difference

    Jul 28, 18 01:45 AM

    Have you found yourself thinking that small healthy changes won’t make much difference? Easier? Sure. Effective? No.

    Read More

  3. Holiday Tips Index Easter Halloween Thanksgiving & Christmas Fun

    Jul 27, 18 02:14 AM

    Lots of tips, recipes, games, and fun ideas in our Holiday Tips Index. Go ahead and make your holidays more fun for all your family and friends. Some of these can turn into pennywise gifts you'll be p…

    Read More